Grammar Tips & Articles »

On Accident vs. By Accident

Ever wondered how prepositions can change the whole meaning of your sentence? Well, in the case of on accident and by accident, only one of them is the right way of using the phrase. In this grammar.com article, let us figure out who wins – on or by!

1:47 min read
61,038 Views
  Ramya Shankar  —  Grammar Tips
Font size:

By accident...

The correct phrase (adverb) to use traditionally, is: ‘by accident’. It means by mistake or something that’s done without the intention of doing it. For example, “she spilled the milk by accident.” We can also use the word ‘accidentally’ as a replacement for by accident – just two ways of referring to the same thing. Some other synonyms of the phrase include unintentionally or by chance.

More examples:

Do you think it is by accident that she got a double promotion?

I opened my mailbox by accident while checking something else and was surprised to see your mail.

Sometimes, what we do or say, even by accident, just backfires; so always be careful.

If I ever hurt your feelings, it was by accident; please let me know so I can apologize.

The glass slipped from my hand by accident.

On accident…

A far less commonly used variant of by accident - on accident, is almost exclusively used in the United States - and incorrectly so. Even there, no one uses ‘on accident’ in writing; it's only a spoken English term. In fact, it is considered incorrect to be used at all.

Now, some people tend to use on accident as they rationalize that it must follow a similar structure to ‘on purpose’ although the meaning is completely the opposite. Yet another cause of confusion is interestingly the word 'accident' itself!

On Accident vs. By Accident

The word accident can be an adjective as in the case: 

We had an accidental meeting.

And it can also be a common noun as in:

The head-on accident led to several injuries and two deaths.

or 

There was no news report on the accident that happened yesterday.

Perhaps the preposition 'on' preceding the word accident is what causes people to use the phrase on accident instead of by accident.

If it is said – “The glass slipped from my hand on accident”, it just doesn’t seem or sound right.

As explained above, on accident is not commonly used as an adverb phrase, if at all. Whereas, ‘by accident’ is the only correct phrase to use when indicating an unintentional or accidentally carried-out action.

Rate this article:

     

Have a discussion about this article with the community:

10 Comments
  • whollygoats
    whollygoats
    Do you think that is all on purpose....or, by accident?
    Why is 'on' correct when there is intention, but 'by' when there is not?
    LikeReply1 year ago
  • apzohvn
    apzohvn
    I appreciate this discussion as I have said to many people, many times, for many years, that things are not done 'on' accident, rather, 'by' accident. So I would pose this question: Do you do things on mistake? LOL! No I do not think so. I'm sure you would say I do things 'by' mistake. Are not accidents and mistakes essentially synonymous? [Unpurposefully done] Therefore, they can only be said one way they are done "by".... 
    LikeReply 31 year ago
  • nuked_f
    nuked_f
    I would love to post this all over social media. People who say on accident drive me crazy. The word "on" implies intention, whereas "by" more accurately describes something that has occurred without direct intention. Thanks 
    LikeReply 233 years ago
    • Soulwriter
      Soulwriter
      haha thanks to you too :)
      LikeReply 13 years ago
    • mrm.41166
      mrm.41166
      this answered my question better than the article. I wondered why it’s, “on purpose” and “by accident.”

      Thank you.
      LikeReply1 year ago
  • tcjessup
    tcjessup
    Perhaps a logical reason why we say "on purpose" but "by accident" is this. "On" implies that things are going correctly (on course, on track, etc.), whereas "by" implies that they have gone astray (fell by the wayside, overcome by events). Thus, an intended outcome happens on purpose, an unintended one by accident (caused by an unanticipated event) or by mistake (caused by an error). 
    LikeReply 73 years ago
    • Soulwriter
      Soulwriter
      I tend to agree with you; well said.
      LikeReply3 years ago
  • DakotaWoods
    DakotaWoods
    Thank you, U. Like you, I had not encountered the phrase in any context until recently. It came up (frequently) in a series of books I was reading and I thought it was the author's "mistake," or perhaps a quirk of hers. 
    LikeReply 23 years ago
  • U
    U
    Sometime you can't worry about over-rationalizing the rules. This article tries to explain things and just makes it more confusing. Fact is, over 40 years and I've never even heard of "on accident" until maybe about 5 years ago. Not in school. Not on TV. Not in conversation. The first time I heard it I thought it was because the guy who said it grew up speaking Spanish and his grammar wasn't very good. Now I hear it everywhere here, even from teachers who should know better and it's driving me crazy. Don't know exactly how long ago it started but it's definitely grown to a point where the overwhelming majority of the population here seem to believe "on accident" is actually how it's said. I actually came here trying to find out if it's some kind of Californian expression or something but this article says United States? At least not where I come from thankfully. 
    LikeReply 13 years ago
  • DakotaWoods
    DakotaWoods
    I don't understand what is meant by "both on and accident are used as independent words in sentences." This seems to be the crux of the explanation why "on accident" can't be used.
    LikeReply3 years ago
    • Soulwriter
      Soulwriter
      hmmm the phrasing there wasn't so clear. The article is out to explain that although, 'on accident' does in theory follow the same rules as 'by accident,' it is not 'correct English' and is not used in written English. 
      LikeReply 13 years ago
  • mryba1988
    mryba1988
    This article given no logical explanation for why "on accident" shouldn't work. What is the structural difference between it and "on purpose"? I don't see one. Simply claiming that it's different because it's different is no explanation at all.

    English prepositions are weird. Why "on a bus"? We ride in a bus, not on it. Using "on" to relate an action to an accident makes no less sense than using "by" or "though". If you're going to write an article chastising people for using the wrong preposition, offer something more substantial as a reason than "because I said so."     
    LikeReply 23 years ago
    • Soulwriter
      Soulwriter
      I share your enthusiasm for grammar accuracy and I hear your complaint loud and clear! As you say, prepositions don't always make sense and come about due to common application that then become the rule. The English language is known to be riddled with contradictions and inconsistency! Not to mention, exceptions to the rules ;)

      I don't believe it's the author's intention to chastise - more to frankly emphasize what is and isn't in use in the instance of the phrase 'by accident.'

      Finally - you've got me thinking...perhaps the difference in prepositions is due to the active or passive nature of the words accident and purpose. 'On' purpose is an active act and intentional. 'By' accident is a passive act and unintended.

      This could also make sense with the phrases: 'On the road,' and 'By the wayside'.

      What do you think?       
      LikeReply 73 years ago
  • emilyr.81851
    emilyr.81851
    Since this is Grammar.com, I'll be pedantic. "Even there, no one uses ‘on accident’ in writing, its only a spoken English term." 1) This should be "it's," not "its." 2) Those clauses should be separated by a semicolon, not a comma; they are complete sentences. 
    LikeReply 53 years ago
    • Soulwriter
      Soulwriter
      Well-spotted! All corrected now. Thanks for that Emily!
      LikeReply 33 years ago
  • Jeffrey Norris
    Jeffrey Norris
    "As we see, on accident cannot be used as an adverb phase, both on and accident are used as independent words in sentences. Whereas, ‘by accident’ is the only correct phrase to indicate unintentionally or accidentally."

    In the above quote, the writer should have written the word phrase, not phase. While both words are legitimate English words, in the above setting, phrase would make sense whereas phase would not.     
    LikeReply 54 years ago

Citation

Use the citation below to add this article to your bibliography:

Style:MLAChicagoAPA

"On Accident vs. By Accident." Grammar.com. STANDS4 LLC, 2024. Web. 21 Nov. 2024. <https://www.grammar.com/on_accident_vs._by_accident>.

Powered by CITE.ME Cite.Me

Checkout our entire collection of

Grammar Articles

Free, no signup required:

Add to Chrome

Check your text and writing for style, spelling and grammar problems everywhere on the web!

Free, no signup required:

Add to Firefox

Check your text and writing for style, spelling and grammar problems everywhere on the web!

Browse Grammar.com

#ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ 

Free Writing Tool:

Instant
Grammar Checker

Improve your grammar, vocabulary, style, and writing — all for FREE!


Quiz

Are you a grammar master?

»
Identify the sentence with a subject-verb agreement error:
A The book on the shelf belongs to Mary.
B Neither the cat nor the dog were hungry.
C The team of players is ready for the match.
D Each of the students has completed their assignment.

Improve your writing now:

Download Grammar eBooks

It’s now more important than ever to develop a powerful writing style. After all, most communication takes place in reports, emails, and instant messages.